| Nov 10, 2004 Wed | | Johnstown | Trenton | Cavanagh-Hayward Lynch-Hayward |
| Nov 12, 2004 Fri | | Peoria | Johnstown | Charpentier-Tremblay Starling-James |
| Nov 17, 2004 Wed | | Johnstown | Wheeling | Lynch-Patrick James-Paddock James-Crampton |
| Dec 18, 2004 Sat | | Dayton | Johnstown | Dix-Van Hoof Kolarik-Tarabrin Brawl at 49:40 |
| Jan 30, 2005 Sun | | Johnstown | Atlantic City | Tremblay-Both Soucy-Walterson |
| Feb 6, 2005 Sun | | Peoria | Johnstown | Kaczowka-James Baker-Olson |
| Feb 20, 2005 Sun | | Trenton | Johnstown | Brown-Sullivan Brown-Sullivan |
| Mar 4, 2005 Fri | | Johnstown | Wheeling | Tarabrin-Rouleau (6) Leinweber-Fata (7) Bilodeau-Morency (8) |
| Mar 11, 2005 Fri | | Atlantic City | Johnstown | Both-Tremblay Heintz-Cavanagh Heintz-James |
| Mar 12, 2005 Sat | | Wheeling | Johnstown | Morency-Tremblay Morency-James |
| Mar 13, 2005 Sun | | Toledo | Johnstown | Snowball-Tremblay Micka-Reid |
| Mar 26, 2005 Sat | | Johnstown | Atlantic City | Collins-Walterson Tremblay-Both |
| Apr 1, 2005 Fri | | Johnstown | Toledo | Bilodeau-Snowball Gallant-Snowball |
| Apr 2, 2005 Sat | | Dayton | Johnstown | Scott-Gallant Sloan-Gallant |
| Apr 8, 2005 Fri | | Trenton | Johnstown | Thompson-Gallant Kowalsky-Tremblay Munn-Gallant |