| Oct 7, 2009 Wed | Preseason | Johnstown | Wheeling | Rechlicz-Harrison
Rechlicz-Harrison
Schwab-Klempa
Hirsch-Clarke |
| Oct 10, 2009 Sat | Preseason | Wheeling | Johnstown | Kalinchuk-Rechlicz |
| Oct 16, 2009 Fri | | Wheeling | South Carolina | Harrison-Finley
Harrison-Kiser |
| Oct 17, 2009 Sat | | Wheeling | Gwinnett | Lord-Miller (5)
(Rough) Harrison-Zanoski |
| Oct 18, 2009 Sun | | Wheeling | Gwinnett | Loya-Miller (4)
Schnell-Couch (5) |
| Oct 23, 2009 Fri | | Cincinnati | Wheeling | Landry-Harrison
Benson-Lord |
| Oct 24, 2009 Sat | | Wheeling | Cincinnati | Lord-Benson (8)
Kalinchuk-McLean |
| Oct 25, 2009 Sun | | Elmira | Wheeling | Gallant-Schnell (6.6) |
| Oct 28, 2009 Wed | | Wheeling | Trenton | Mini-Brawl at 25:13
Harrison-Stoesz
Schnell-Eves
Loya-Coutu |
| Oct 30, 2009 Fri | | Kalamazoo | Wheeling | Jurynec-Lord (7)
Bootland-Lord |
| Oct 31, 2009 Sat | | Cincinnati | Wheeling | Sproat-Ganzak |
| Nov 6, 2009 Fri | | South Carolina | Wheeling | Carbery-Ganzak |
| Nov 7, 2009 Sat | | Johnstown | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Nov 13, 2009 Fri | | Wheeling | Johnstown | Lord-Hendrikx (3)
Loya-Schulz
Clarke-Sinkewich |
| Nov 14, 2009 Sat | | Johnstown | Wheeling | (Rough) Gutierrez-Beauregard
(Almost) Hendrikx-Schnell |
| Nov 20, 2009 Fri | | Wheeling | Elmira | Schnell-Spencer (5) |
| Nov 21, 2009 Sat | | Wheeling | Elmira | Schnell-Turner
Lord-Lepine |
| Nov 25, 2009 Wed | | Florida | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Nov 27, 2009 Fri | | Wheeling | Elmira | Schnell-Gallant (4) |
| Nov 28, 2009 Sat | | Cincinnati | Wheeling | O'Leary-Lord |
| Nov 29, 2009 Sun | | Cincinnati | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Dec 2, 2009 Wed | | Wheeling | Johnstown | Schnell-Schulz |
| Dec 4, 2009 Fri | | Wheeling | Johnstown | Bushee-Deeth |
| Dec 5, 2009 Sat | | Johnstown | Wheeling | Schulz-Lord |
| Dec 6, 2009 Sun | | Toledo | Wheeling | MacMillan-Lord
(Rough) Hedden-Pierro-Zabotel |
| Dec 9, 2009 Wed | | Wheeling | Toledo | Lord-MacMillan
Schnell-Stokes
(Rough) Schmidt-Osman |
| Dec 11, 2009 Fri | | Gwinnett | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Dec 12, 2009 Sat | | Wheeling | Kalamazoo | (Rough) Schnell-Curadeau
Lord-Jurynec (5.5)
Power-Peralta (2.5)
Ganzak-Friesen (5) |
| Dec 13, 2009 Sun | | Gwinnett | Wheeling | (Rough) Denny-Schnell |
| Dec 16, 2009 Wed | | Wheeling | Florida | Schnell-Olson (8) |
| Dec 18, 2009 Fri | | Wheeling | Florida | Add Fight |
| Dec 19, 2009 Sat | | Wheeling | Florida | Lord-McJannet (8) |
| Dec 26, 2009 Sat | | Wheeling | Kalamazoo | (Rough) Grant-Morrow |
| Dec 27, 2009 Sun | | Elmira | Wheeling | Gallant-Schnell (7.3)
(Rough) Lepine-Lord |
| Dec 30, 2009 Wed | | Wheeling | Reading | Power-Kwiet
Lord-Langdon |
| Dec 31, 2009 Thu | | Toledo | Wheeling | MacMillan-Schmidt |
| Jan 2, 2010 Sat | | Wheeling | Trenton | Add Fight |
| Jan 8, 2010 Fri | | Cincinnati | Wheeling | Benson-Schnell
(Cheap) Lacroix-Thiessen
Lacroix-Pierro-Zabotel
Sheahan-Power |
| Jan 9, 2010 Sat | | Johnstown | Wheeling | (Cheap) McKenzie-Sill
(Rough) Hendrikx-Lord |
| Jan 12, 2010 Tue | | Wheeling | Cincinnati | Power-Benson (2) |
| Jan 15, 2010 Fri | | Toledo | Wheeling | Nebus-Schnell
Suda-Power |
| Jan 16, 2010 Sat | | Johnstown | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Jan 17, 2010 Sun | | Elmira | Wheeling | Lepine-Lord |
| Jan 22, 2010 Fri | | Wheeling | Charlotte | Schnell-Reynolds |
| Jan 24, 2010 Sun | | Wheeling | South Carolina | Add Fight |
| Jan 26, 2010 Tue | | Wheeling | South Carolina | Add Fight |
| Jan 30, 2010 Sat | | South Carolina | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Jan 31, 2010 Sun | | South Carolina | Wheeling | Kiser-Lord (4)
Dubuc-Lord |
| Feb 3, 2010 Wed | | Wheeling | Cincinnati | Add Fight |
| Feb 5, 2010 Fri | | Wheeling | Elmira | Lord-Spencer
Boogaard-Turner
Ganzak-Korchinski |
| Feb 6, 2010 Sat | | Kalamazoo | Wheeling | (Rough) Strong-Fox |
| Feb 9, 2010 Tue | | Johnstown | Wheeling | Martens-Power
(Rough) Schwab-Haddad |
| Feb 12, 2010 Fri | | Elmira | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Feb 13, 2010 Sat | | Elmira | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Feb 14, 2010 Sun | | Wheeling | Reading | Boogaard-Langdon
Lord-Clark
Power-Clark |
| Feb 19, 2010 Fri | | Wheeling | Cincinnati | (Rough) D'Aversa-Lacroix |
| Feb 20, 2010 Sat | | Wheeling | Cincinnati | (Rough) D'Aversa-Morehouse
(Rough) Pierro-Zabotel-Lacroix |
| Feb 21, 2010 Sun | | Wheeling | Trenton | (Rough) Loya-Zancanaro
(Rough) Caffaro-Murray |
| Feb 24, 2010 Wed | | Wheeling | Cincinnati | Add Fight |
| Feb 26, 2010 Fri | | Wheeling | Reading | Add Fight |
| Feb 27, 2010 Sat | | Wheeling | Elmira | Schnell-Spencer |
| Mar 5, 2010 Fri | | Charlotte | Wheeling | DiDiomete-Lord |
| Mar 6, 2010 Sat | | Trenton | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Mar 7, 2010 Sun | | Trenton | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Mar 13, 2010 Sat | | Wheeling | Johnstown | Power-Martens |
| Mar 14, 2010 Sun | | Kalamazoo | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Mar 17, 2010 Wed | | Wheeling | Kalamazoo | Add Fight |
| Mar 19, 2010 Fri | | Wheeling | Kalamazoo | Bushee-Strong
Power-McGinnis |
| Mar 20, 2010 Sat | | Kalamazoo | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Mar 21, 2010 Sun | | Toledo | Wheeling | Nebus-Schnell |
| Mar 26, 2010 Fri | | Kalamazoo | Wheeling | Add Fight |
| Mar 27, 2010 Sat | | Wheeling | Toledo | Add Fight |
| Apr 2, 2010 Fri | | Reading | Wheeling | Langdon-Lord (4)
(Cheap) unknown-Schnell (5)
unknown-Lord (1) |
| Apr 3, 2010 Sat | | Cincinnati | Wheeling | Sproat-Fox |