| Nov 6, 2011 Sun | | Fayetteville | Columbus | Needham-Cianfrini McNeil-Wall |
| Nov 12, 2011 Sat | | Fayetteville | Huntsville | Needham-Boutin-Gagnon (7.5) Willock-Cannata |
| Dec 2, 2011 Fri | | Fayetteville | Huntsville | Nicholls-Brown McNeil-Boutin-Gagnon (6) |
| Dec 10, 2011 Sat | | Fayetteville | Louisiana | Mini-Brawl at 21:10 Smith-Hill McNeil-Simoes |
| Dec 17, 2011 Sat | | Fayetteville | Knoxville | McNeil-Segal (4) Hlookoff-Valliquette |
| Dec 27, 2011 Tue | | Fayetteville | Columbus | Watt-Barlow Smyth-Amesbury (5) McNeil-Amesbury (5) |
| Jan 20, 2012 Fri | | Mississippi S | Fayetteville | Siers-McNeil (3) Brawl at 51:30 Ridley-Frieday Smiley-Brown (7) |
| Jan 22, 2012 Sun | | Mississippi S | Fayetteville | Brawl at 58:22 (5.5) Kinnunen-McNeil (4) Isaacs-Smyth (3) Smiley-Hudson (6) |
| Feb 17, 2012 Fri | | Huntsville | Fayetteville | Mini-Brawl at 60:00 Brown-McNeil Sicard-Smyth |