| Sep 16, 1989 Sat | Preseason | New Jersey | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Sep 20, 1989 Wed | Preseason | New Jersey | NY Rangers | Stewart-Mallette
Stewart-King (6)
MacLean-Nilan
Daneyko-Mallette (2)
Muller-Hardy (8) |
| Sep 22, 1989 Fri | Preseason | New Jersey | Hartford | Add Fight |
| Sep 23, 1989 Sat | Preseason | Philadelphia | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Sep 24, 1989 Sun | Preseason | New Jersey | Minnesota | Add Fight |
| Sep 26, 1989 Tue | Preseason | NY Rangers | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Sep 27, 1989 Wed | Preseason | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Sep 28, 1989 Thu | Preseason | NY Islanders | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Oct 5, 1989 Thu | | New Jersey | Philadelphia | Velischek-Berube (4) |
| Oct 7, 1989 Sat | | Pittsburgh | New Jersey | Johnson-Maley
Caufield-Shanahan (4.3)
Johnson-MacLean (3) |
| Oct 10, 1989 Tue | | Calgary | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Oct 13, 1989 Fri | | Montreal | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Oct 14, 1989 Sat | | New Jersey | Hartford | Maley-Kastelic (5) |
| Oct 18, 1989 Wed | | Philadelphia | New Jersey | Chychrun-Maley |
| Oct 20, 1989 Fri | | Vancouver | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Oct 21, 1989 Sat | | New Jersey | Montreal | Add Fight |
| Oct 23, 1989 Mon | | New Jersey | Toronto | Brawl at 37:14 (8.5)
Maley-Marsh (3)
Burke-Laforest (8.5)
Fetisov-Clark (4.8)
Muller-Richardson (1)
Scrum at 45:59 (5)
Shanahan-Franceschetti (1) |
| Oct 26, 1989 Thu | | Hartford | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Oct 28, 1989 Sat | | Chicago | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Oct 31, 1989 Tue | | New Jersey | Vancouver | Add Fight |
| Nov 1, 1989 Wed | | New Jersey | Edmonton | Add Fight |
| Nov 4, 1989 Sat | | New Jersey | Calgary | Add Fight |
| Nov 8, 1989 Wed | | Quebec | New Jersey | Dore-Daneyko (4) |
| Nov 11, 1989 Sat | | Philadelphia | New Jersey | Scrum (2)
Tocchet-Daneyko (6)
(Cheap) Murphy-MacLean (5) |
| Nov 12, 1989 Sun | | New Jersey | Philadelphia | Maley-Chychrun
Scrum at 24:24 |
| Nov 15, 1989 Wed | | Minnesota | New Jersey | (Hit) Berezan-Daneyko (2)
Zettler-Turgeon (5.3)
Tinordi-Maley (5.3) |
| Nov 17, 1989 Fri | | NY Rangers | New Jersey | Janssens-Burke (3) |
| Nov 18, 1989 Sat | | New Jersey | Boston | Shanahan-Sweeney (4.7) |
| Nov 22, 1989 Wed | | New Jersey | Pittsburgh | Shanahan-Loney (5.8)
Broten-Coffey
Poddubny-Dineen (3) |
| Nov 24, 1989 Fri | | New Jersey | Minnesota | Broten-Zettler (5) |
| Nov 25, 1989 Sat | | New Jersey | Winnipeg | Add Fight |
| Nov 28, 1989 Tue | | NY Islanders | New Jersey | Vukota-Maley (4)
(Rough) Vukota-Maley |
| Dec 1, 1989 Fri | | New Jersey | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Dec 2, 1989 Sat | | Washington | New Jersey | May-Daneyko (3) |
| Dec 6, 1989 Wed | | New Jersey | NY Rangers | Velischek-King (3)
Maley-Mallette |
| Dec 8, 1989 Fri | | Pittsburgh | New Jersey | Hillier-Korn |
| Dec 9, 1989 Sat | | New Jersey | Hartford | Add Fight |
| Dec 12, 1989 Tue | | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Maley-Diduck
Daneyko-Vukota (5.5)
Huscroft-Vukota (7)
Maley-Baumgartner (6) |
| Dec 13, 1989 Wed | | NY Islanders | New Jersey | Vukota-Brady (4)
Maloney-Velischek (1) |
| Dec 15, 1989 Fri | | Los Angeles | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Dec 17, 1989 Sun | | Boston | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Dec 19, 1989 Tue | | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Dec 22, 1989 Fri | | New Jersey | Philadelphia | Add Fight |
| Dec 23, 1989 Sat | | St. Louis | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Dec 26, 1989 Tue | | New Jersey | NY Rangers | Huscroft-King
Maley-Mallette |
| Dec 27, 1989 Wed | | Washington | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Dec 29, 1989 Fri | | NY Rangers | New Jersey | Scrum at 31:04 |
| Dec 31, 1989 Sun | | New Jersey | Detroit | Huscroft-Kocur (5) |
| Jan 2, 1990 Tue | | Buffalo | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Jan 4, 1990 Thu | | Los Angeles | New Jersey | McSorley-Maley (6.8) |
| Jan 8, 1990 Mon | | Winnipeg | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Jan 10, 1990 Wed | | Pittsburgh | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Jan 12, 1990 Fri | | Montreal | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Jan 13, 1990 Sat | | New Jersey | Quebec | Velischek-DeBlois
Shanahan-Finn |
| Jan 16, 1990 Tue | | New Jersey | Washington | Daneyko-May |
| Jan 23, 1990 Tue | | New Jersey | Pittsburgh | Daneyko-Brown
(Cheap) unknown-Dineen |
| Jan 24, 1990 Wed | | Washington | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Jan 26, 1990 Fri | | Toronto | New Jersey | (Rough) Fergus-Fetisov
(Hit) Clark-Fetisov
Mini-Brawl at 54:38
Clark-Fetisov (8.5) |
| Jan 28, 1990 Sun | | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Huscroft-Vukota (4) |
| Jan 30, 1990 Tue | | New Jersey | Los Angeles | Daneyko-McSorley (6) |
| Feb 4, 1990 Sun | | New Jersey | Vancouver | Add Fight |
| Feb 6, 1990 Tue | | Edmonton | New Jersey | MacTavish-Muller |
| Feb 9, 1990 Fri | | New Jersey | Washington | Scrum at 3:52
Wolanin-Sheehy (6.5) |
| Feb 10, 1990 Sat | | New Jersey | St. Louis | Huscroft-Cavallini
Brawl at 30:43 (5)
Daneyko-Chase (7)
Thomson-Featherstone (2)
(Cheap) Thomson-unknown |
| Feb 12, 1990 Mon | | Detroit | New Jersey | McClelland-Thomson (5) |
| Feb 16, 1990 Fri | | NY Rangers | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Feb 17, 1990 Sat | | New Jersey | Toronto | Crowder-Kordic (8.1)
Korn-Curran (3.6)
Crowd Trouble at 6:36 (5.2)
Muller-Daoust (1)
(Refused) Maley-Curran (2)
MacLean-Ramage (0) |
| Feb 19, 1990 Mon | | New Jersey | NY Rangers | (Rough) Shanahan-Moller (3)
Shanahan-Janssens (6) |
| Feb 22, 1990 Thu | | Winnipeg | New Jersey | Cronin-Turgeon (3.7) |
| Feb 24, 1990 Sat | | Chicago | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Feb 25, 1990 Sun | | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Huscroft-Vukota (6) |
| Feb 28, 1990 Wed | | New Jersey | Pittsburgh | Add Fight |
| Mar 2, 1990 Fri | | Pittsburgh | New Jersey | Zemlak-Daneyko (6)
Johnson-Turgeon (4)
(Almost) Kyte-Huscroft |
| Mar 4, 1990 Sun | | New Jersey | Washington | Huscroft-Sheehy |
| Mar 6, 1990 Tue | | St. Louis | New Jersey | Chase-Huscroft (3)
Dirk-Huscroft |
| Mar 8, 1990 Thu | | NY Islanders | New Jersey | Scrum
Scrum at 30:30 |
| Mar 10, 1990 Sat | | Quebec | New Jersey | Petit-Shanahan (8.7)
Finn-Huscroft
(Almost) Petit-Shanahan (3.5) |
| Mar 13, 1990 Tue | | New Jersey | Minnesota | Velischek-Churla (4) |
| Mar 15, 1990 Thu | | New Jersey | Calgary | Add Fight |
| Mar 17, 1990 Sat | | New Jersey | Edmonton | Add Fight |
| Mar 20, 1990 Tue | | Philadelphia | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Mar 22, 1990 Thu | | New Jersey | Chicago | Maley-Creighton |
| Mar 24, 1990 Sat | | New Jersey | Philadelphia | Add Fight |
| Mar 25, 1990 Sun | | New Jersey | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Mar 27, 1990 Tue | | Washington | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Mar 29, 1990 Thu | | NY Rangers | New Jersey | King-Daneyko (7)
King-Huscroft (1)
Ruff-Huscroft (2)
Janssens-Daneyko (4)
Mallette-Shanahan (5.7) |
| Mar 31, 1990 Sat | | Detroit | New Jersey | Scrum at 43:14 |
| Apr 1, 1990 Sun | | New Jersey | Boston | Weinrich-Hawgood (1)
Maley-Galley (1)
Huscroft-Burridge (5) |
| Apr 5, 1990 Thu | Round 1 | Game 1 | Washington | New Jersey | (Hit) Rouse-Shanahan (4)
Courtnall-Muller
Druce-Daneyko (4) |
| Apr 7, 1990 Sat | Round 1 | Game 2 | Washington | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Apr 9, 1990 Mon | Round 1 | Game 3 | New Jersey | Washington | Add Fight |
| Apr 11, 1990 Wed | Round 1 | Game 4 | New Jersey | Washington | Add Fight |
| Apr 13, 1990 Fri | Round 1 | Game 5 | Washington | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Apr 15, 1990 Sun | Round 1 | Game 6 | New Jersey | Washington | Add Fight |