| Oct 11, 2003 Sat | | St. John's | Manitoba | Holden-Smith Brown-Grenier (2) Moro-Grenier |
| Oct 13, 2003 Mon | | St. John's | Manitoba | Moro-Kavanagh |
| Oct 15, 2003 Wed | | Hershey | St. John's | Stephens-Moro (2.5) Richardson-Newbury (5) |
| Oct 16, 2003 Thu | | Hershey | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Oct 18, 2003 Sat | | Manitoba | St. John's | Grenier-Brown (5) Roy-Newbury Ready-Harrison (8) |
| Oct 19, 2003 Sun | | Manitoba | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Oct 24, 2003 Fri | | St. John's | Portland | Brown-Verot Brown-Yonkman |
| Oct 26, 2003 Sun | | St. John's | Portland | Add Fight |
| Oct 28, 2003 Tue | | Milwaukee | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Oct 29, 2003 Wed | | Milwaukee | St. John's | Henderson-Moro (3) |
| Nov 1, 2003 Sat | | St. John's | Binghamton | Add Fight |
| Nov 2, 2003 Sun | | St. John's | Toronto | Brown-Thompson (5.7) (Rough) Newbury-Baum (2) Harrison-McAslan (2.5) |
| Nov 5, 2003 Wed | | St. John's | Hershey | Brown-Jerant |
| Nov 7, 2003 Fri | | St. John's | Hamilton | Add Fight |
| Nov 8, 2003 Sat | | St. John's | Binghamton | Wilm-Payer |
| Nov 14, 2003 Fri | | Chicago | St. John's | Ustrnul-Brown (5) |
| Nov 15, 2003 Sat | | Chicago | St. John's | Sellars-Brown (Rough) Weaver-Palahnuk (3) Blatny-Daw (3.7) DiPenta-Newbury (3.5) Weaver-Newbury (8) |
| Nov 18, 2003 Tue | | Hamilton | St. John's | Carpentier-Brown |
| Nov 19, 2003 Wed | | Hamilton | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Nov 21, 2003 Fri | | Grand Rapids | St. John's | Barnes-Brown (4) |
| Nov 22, 2003 Sat | | Grand Rapids | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Nov 26, 2003 Wed | | St. John's | Milwaukee | Harrison-Henderson |
| Nov 28, 2003 Fri | | St. John's | Cleveland | Add Fight |
| Nov 29, 2003 Sat | | St. John's | Chicago | Palahnuk-Baby (3.5) |
| Dec 3, 2003 Wed | | St. John's | Cleveland | Wilm-Hansen |
| Dec 5, 2003 Fri | | St. John's | Cleveland | Harrison-Carkner (4.5) |
| Dec 6, 2003 Sat | | St. John's | Grand Rapids | Add Fight |
| Dec 9, 2003 Tue | | Rochester | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Dec 10, 2003 Wed | | Rochester | St. John's | McMorrow-Moro (4) Gaustad-Druken (5.5) Scrum at 51:45 (3) Roy-Newbury (5) McMorrow-Wilm (6) (Rough) Mosovsky-Leeb (2) Gaustad-Moro (3) |
| Dec 12, 2003 Fri | | Binghamton | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Dec 13, 2003 Sat | | Binghamton | St. John's | Langfeld-Moro (5.5) |
| Dec 19, 2003 Fri | | St. John's | Toronto | Moro-Winchester (6.3) Scrum at 18:44 Lakovic-Thompson (6.3) Colaiacovo-Wright (3) Palahnuk-Henrich (5.5) Lakovic-Thompson (6.3) |
| Dec 20, 2003 Sat | | St. John's | Syracuse | Harrison-Reich Lakovic-Sugden (6) |
| Dec 21, 2003 Sun | | St. John's | Hershey | Newbury-Richardson Moro-Artyukhin Newbury-Smith |
| Dec 27, 2003 Sat | | St. John's | Hamilton | Harrison-Blouin |
| Dec 28, 2003 Sun | | St. John's | Hamilton | Add Fight |
| Jan 2, 2004 Fri | | St. John's | Toronto | Palahnuk-Henrich (1) Wilm-Roy (4) Wilm-Roy (6) |
| Jan 3, 2004 Sat | | St. John's | Cleveland | Add Fight |
| Jan 6, 2004 Tue | | Manitoba | St. John's | Roy-Palahnuk |
| Jan 7, 2004 Wed | | Manitoba | St. John's | Grenier-Lakovic (7) |
| Jan 9, 2004 Fri | | Toronto | St. John's | Henley-Lakovic (6) Roche-Moro Scrum at 59:28 |
| Jan 10, 2004 Sat | | Toronto | St. John's | Line Brawl at 28:28 (9) Henley-Harrison (7) Woywitka-Palahnuk (7) Wright-Ondrus (5) Baum-Newbury (9) |
| Jan 14, 2004 Wed | | St. John's | Chicago | (Rough) Moro-Heins Gavey-Stewart (5) Palahnuk-Heins (4) |
| Jan 16, 2004 Fri | | St. John's | Milwaukee | Event at 15:49 |
| Jan 17, 2004 Sat | | St. John's | Grand Rapids | Add Fight |
| Jan 27, 2004 Tue | | Hamilton | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Jan 28, 2004 Wed | | Hamilton | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Jan 30, 2004 Fri | | Cleveland | St. John's | Labenski-Palahnuk Murray-Gagnon (6) |
| Jan 31, 2004 Sat | | Cleveland | St. John's | Clowe-Gagnon (7) Murray-Palahnuk (3) (Rough) Fahey-Moro |
| Feb 3, 2004 Tue | | Syracuse | St. John's | Cull-Palahnuk |
| Feb 4, 2004 Wed | | Syracuse | St. John's | Sugden-Gagnon (4) Komarniski-Harrison |
| Feb 6, 2004 Fri | | St. John's | Toronto | Newbury-Henrich (3) |
| Feb 7, 2004 Sat | | St. John's | Hamilton | Add Fight |
| Feb 11, 2004 Wed | | St. John's | Hamilton | Add Fight |
| Feb 13, 2004 Fri | | St. John's | Rochester | Add Fight |
| Feb 15, 2004 Sun | | St. John's | Rochester | Wilm-Botterill |
| Feb 20, 2004 Fri | | Cleveland | St. John's | Cloutier-Moro |
| Feb 21, 2004 Sat | | Cleveland | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Feb 27, 2004 Fri | | Portland | St. John's | Hajt-Holden (7) |
| Feb 28, 2004 Sat | | Portland | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Mar 5, 2004 Fri | | Toronto | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Mar 6, 2004 Sat | | Toronto | St. John's | Thompson-Gagnon Hunter-Newbury (5) |
| Mar 12, 2004 Fri | | St. John's | Toronto | Lehoux-Winchester |
| Mar 13, 2004 Sat | | St. John's | Syracuse | Ondrus-Buckley |
| Mar 14, 2004 Sun | | St. John's | Rochester | Add Fight |
| Mar 16, 2004 Tue | | Rochester | St. John's | Lingren-Ondrus (2.5) Peters-Harrison (5.5) McMorrow-Lehoux (5) |
| Mar 17, 2004 Wed | | Rochester | St. John's | Peters-Palahnuk (3) |
| Mar 19, 2004 Fri | | Hamilton | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Mar 20, 2004 Sat | | Hamilton | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Mar 24, 2004 Wed | | St. John's | Syracuse | Add Fight |
| Mar 26, 2004 Fri | | St. John's | Hamilton | Add Fight |
| Mar 27, 2004 Sat | | St. John's | Syracuse | Holden-Limpright Palahnuk-Cull Lehoux-Sugden (6) |
| Mar 31, 2004 Wed | | St. John's | Rochester | Harrison-Gaustad (4) Newbury-Thorburn (5) |
| Apr 1, 2004 Thu | | St. John's | Toronto | Ondrus-Hogan (2) |
| Apr 2, 2004 Fri | | St. John's | Manitoba | Wilm-Roy |
| Apr 4, 2004 Sun | | St. John's | Manitoba | Add Fight |
| Apr 6, 2004 Tue | | Syracuse | St. John's | Add Fight |
| Apr 7, 2004 Wed | | Syracuse | St. John's | Reich-Wilm |
| Apr 9, 2004 Fri | | Toronto | St. John's | Stortini-Ondrus |
| Apr 10, 2004 Sat | | Toronto | St. John's | Scrum at 49:53 |