| # | Player | Comments |
| 1 | Doug Gilmour | KILLER was the most gutsy player I ever saw play. The image of him breaking the glass in the penalty box by slamming the door when he was with Montreal will live in my mind for eternity. |
| 2 | Steve Yzerman | Absolutely one of the best ever! Good luck in future endevours, My captain |
| 3 | Wendel Clark | Family owns a logging compay-no wonder he could fight |
| 4 | Felix Potvin | Felix Potvin vs. Ron Hextall-best goalie fight I've ever seen |
| 5 | Ron Hextall | SEE:FELIX POTVIN |
| 6 | Ray Bourque | Best Defenceman for it EVER, period |
| 7 | Kelly Buchberger | He has always been a great teammate-he would be good in Washington right now-they need leadership |
| 8 | Theoren Fleury | Tough little guy. Hard to figure out why a recovering alcoholic would want to play in Ireland though |
| 9 | Cam Neely | Good addition to Hall of Fame-amazingly gifted |
| 10 | Al Iafrate | Could fight and score-tough combo |
| 11 | Jarome Iginla | Cam Neely clone-and thats a good thing |
| 12 | Nick Kypreos | Not a very good fighter, But really good on HockeyCentral on Roger's Sportsnet |
| 13 | Ted Lindsay | Don't know much about him, sounds like he could really throw them |
| 14 | Nicklas Lidstrom | One of the best defencemen of all time-a lock for the Hall-but who did he fight? |
| 15 | Kevin Lowe | Not to many more classy guys like him in the League |
| 16 | Al MacInnis | It's a bird, It's a plane, It's Big Al's slap shot! |
| 17 | Darren McCarty | Totally justified it Claude Lemieux pummelling, mean lookin s.o.b. |
| 18 | Lanny McDonald | Always liked Yosemite Sam |
| 19 | Mark Messier | Was a good fighter, didn't have to in later years |
| 20 | Dion Phaneuf | Amazing hitter, dropped Ovechkin in World Juniors-Can't beat a good Double-Dion |
| 21 | Scott Niedermayer | Good to see him out of the swamp (jersey) |
| 22 | Mike Richards | This kid is going to be great! |
| 23 | Jimmy Roy | Heart and soul of Manitoba Moose-hell of a fighter |
| 24 | Robyn Regehr | Teamed with Phaneuf, Calgary has good defence for many years
|
| 25 | Dave Van Drunen | Played Junior hockey in Prince Albert sask, best fight i ever saw-took guys helmet off and broke it over his head! AMAZING |
| 26 | Joe Thornton | He's a tough shit. |
| 27 | Brendan Shanahan | Would have been awsome to see him line up with Cam-team mates or toe to toe |
| 28 | Jason Smith | Tough as nails |
| 29 | Ryan Smyth | Captain Canada! Always heeds the call of duty! |
| 30 | Pat Verbeek | Gritty with a good touch around the net |
| 31 | Mike Vernon | Everybody brings up Roy, Mikey held his own too! |
| 32 | Shea Weber | 11/28/2005-mark my words, this kid will be amazing |
| 33 | Steve Ott | A true spark plug! |
| 34 | Alex Ovechkin | If he had a set-up man, he would be even more dynamic (if that is possible) |