| # | Player | Comments |
| 1 | Stephen Peat | Didnt care if he got hit, he just stood back and threw bombs. |
| 2 | Behn Wilson | Toughest of all the great flyer heavyweights, including Dave Brown. He was just plain scary, not many players even considered trying to forecheck when he was on the ice. |
| 3 | Ken Baumgartner | For a small heavyweight kenny was top 10 in the league almost every year he played. Very good in tight, tactically sound fighter with a wicked left hand. |
| 4 | Patrick Marleau | One of the best all around players in the league. Extremely underrated as a 2 way forward and a captain. A true gentleman of the game. |
| 5 | Sean Avery | Who gives a shit about his personal life or if he likes to wear womens designer underwear or not. He brings excitement, heart, passion, and a level of grit to the game that dare I say rivals the likes of dale hunter. The NHL has taken advantage of his bad boy image and punished him for it. Wouldn't you be pissed if you found out that an opposing teams player fucked your ex girlfriend? Possibly he had feelings for her, keep your own personal experiences in mind before you judge him on some dumbass comment he said in canada. |
| 6 | Rob Ray | Heart and soul of the sabres for many years. I feel his 32 should be retired in buffalo. |
| 7 | Bob Gassoff | Dave schultz described him as "scary" . |