| # | Player | Comments |
| 1 | Milan Lucic | Granted, Milan Lucic is definitely amongst the toughest in the NHL today out of the other fighter's his age, but he tends to be pretty cocky compared to many of the legit fighters in the league. I also think he is pretty scared of the "heavyweights" of the league, and picks his spots when he decides to shed the mitts. He shows very little respect. |
| 2 | Sean Avery | As Don Cherry said, its only a matter of time before this guy gets seriously hurt.. |
| 3 | Tie Domi | Definitely tough for his size. But he had an ego that I always hated. |
| 4 | Claude Lemieux | A Dirty Pussy...That is all. |