| # | Player | Comments |
| 1 | Darcy Hordichuk | Head down fighter and personally my favourite NHL player |
| 2 | George Parros | Has a good record the last 2 years but not this year |
| 3 | Matt Carkner | Fights anyone all the time |
| 4 | Georges Laraque | Top 3 Heavyweight in the league |
| 5 | Colton Orr | Top 5 Heavyweight in the league |
| 6 | Eric Godard | Top 3 Heavyweight in the league |
| 7 | Eric Boulton | Having a great 2009-2010 season so far in terms of fighting |
| 8 | Shawn Thornton | Stands up for his mates |
| 9 | Sheldon Brookbank | Good 6-7 defense man, good middleweight |
| 10 | Mike Brown | A hugger but can always be seen fighting |
| 11 | Brian McGrattan | Top 5 Heavyweight in the league, having a good season in Calgary |
| 12 | Rick Rypien | Best fighter in the league? With wins over monster's Hal Gill and Andy Sutton. Still needs to prove he can fight the Colton Orr's of the league |
| 13 | Brandon Prust | Will drop the mits with anyone anywhere |
| 14 | Tim Conboy | Still adapting to the NHL game and NHL heavyweights, may end up being a descent middle weight in the long run |
| 15 | Ben Eager | Doesn't fight as much as he used to but still will fight when his mates are down, has developed into a power forward |
| 16 | David Koci | Big doesn't necessarily mean you are a good fighter. He is always fighting the big boys but rarely picks up the win, I have respect for anyone who can take a few punches |
| 17 | Jared Boll | I don't like his hair but I like his style which is fighting |
| 18 | Krys Barch | Considers himself a heavy weight but is lacking in the win department, I think he would do good against players like Tim Conboy, Brandon Prust and Mike Brown, but I respect that he takes on the league's heavies |
| 19 | Brad May | Used to be an excellent fighter who fought the heavyweights of the league but has wisely dropped into that middle weight division |
| 20 | Zack Stortini | Switched up his style a bit and can always been caught trying to start a fight |
| 21 | Steve MacIntyre | A true heavyweight but needs to work on his fighting skill, is effective when he plays under 2 minutes a game |
| 22 | Raitis Ivanans | Top 10 Heavyweight in the league |
| 23 | Derek Boogaard | Top 5 Heavyweight in the league, the only guys who can beat him are Eric Godard and Georges Laraque. I would like to see him fight a bit more |
| 24 | Wade Belak | Could be the best heavyweight in the league right now with a knockout win on top tough guy Donald Brashear |
| 25 | Andrew Peters | Top 10 heavyweight in the league at 247 pounds |
| 26 | David Clarkson | Descent middle weight but has dropped off fighting early in the 2010 season |
| 27 | Pierre-Luc Leblond | Had a notable tilt against Donald Brashear last season but his lack of skating ability is keeping him out of the lineup, to be affective his time needs to be cut to 3 minutes a game |
| 28 | Tim Jackman | Didn't expect him to fight as much as he did last season but has signed him self up for the heavyweight division |
| 29 | Joel Rechlicz | This guy is gonna be a future World Heavyweight Champion of the NHL, hopefully he gets a full season in with the Isles soon |
| 30 | Jeremy Reich | Good middleweight fighter who can also fight the heavies, played good in Providence last season and a good pick up for the Isles fourth line with Jackman |
| 31 | Donald Brashear | The Don as I call him confuses me, some days he impresses me and some days he looks awful, he is the kind of guy who gets better with age. I would still put him as a top enforcer of the NHL |
| 32 | Chris Neil | This guy loves to bleed, he bleeds in most of his fights and loves to pump up the crowd, middleweight size but tends to fight the league's heavies |
| 33 | Riley Cote | Mr. Black Eyes, black eye should be Cote's middle name. Riley is as tough as nails but doesn't get into the lineup enough |
| 34 | Ole-Kristian Tollefsen | I believe Tollefsen and David Koci are the only European players to fight in the game today which is nice to see, Ole-Kristian is a solid 5-6 defenseman which is a good signing for the Flyers |
| 35 | Paul Bissonnette | Paul in the future could be in a World Heavyweight Championship feud with Joel Rechlicz, Paul is tough but tends to do more fighting in the AHL than the NHL for some reason |
| 36 | Jody Shelley | Jody Shelley has picked it up this year, he is playing like he did a few years ago with the Blue Jackets. I think he could finish top 5 in fighting majors this season |
| 37 | Cam Janssen | Cam is a great fighter who fights all the heavies in the league, at roughly 6'0 and 210 pounds is an effective 4th liner but tends to get into penalty trouble when he plays more than 5 minutes a game |
| 38 | D.J. King | D.J. King could be one of the best young enforcers in the league today, with a win over Jody Shelley a couple of seasons ago he has impressed early and will hopefully do so in the future if he can keep from getting injured if not he may find himself on the trading block with home town tough guy Cam Janssen already on the roster |
| 39 | Zenon Konopka | Zenon Konopka is a willing middle weight and started his first 4 games with a fight in every game and hasn't fought since which isn't a good sign. Zenon was impressive in the 2009-2010 preseason with a large number of fights |
| 40 | Jamal Mayers | Jamal Mayers tried to be a heavyweight last season in the absence of an actual enforcer other than Andre Deveaux on the Leafs roster, lets just say he failed miserably. It appears so far in the 2009-2010 season that Mayers has dropped down to the middle weight division which may have been a good decision for him |
| 41 | Chris Simon | Chris Simon is currently playing in the KHL after a string of suspensions in the NHL, despite his history of mishaps in the NHL he is a very capable enforcer and I would love to see him in the NHL again soon |
| 42 | Andre Roy | Andre Roy is currently an unrestricted free agent. If anyone has any information on his status please message me, Andre can play 6 to 8 minutes for any NHL team and can also chip in with a few goals, It is believed that Roy's history of anger has kept him from NHL employment this season |
| 43 | Aaron Downey | After a tryout with the Phoenix Coyotes tallying no fights he has disappeared from the NHL universe. Aaron is a free agent |
| 44 | Ryley Grantham | Don't know much about this kid other than he can't stop dropping his gloves in the American League |
| 45 | J.D. Watt | After a full AHL season in 08-09 season J.D. Watt has been demoted to the ECHL for the 2009-2010 season, hopefully Watt can find himself with Abbotsford soon as he has turned out to be an excellent middleweight |
| 46 | Peter Vandermeer | Peter's penalty minutes has dropped off the last couple seasons but still finds him self logging 150 penalty minutes a season, Peter is a good veteran AHL enforcer |
| 47 | Jay Rosehill | Jay Rosehill has found him self logging NHL minutes this season after a 35 fight season in the AHL, Rosehill has recently been scratched the last few games |
| 48 | Matt Clackson | With a middleweight build Matt Clackson has fitted well in the AHL, he loves to fight the heavies but sometimes has trouble picking up the victories against the heavies |
| 49 | Garrett Klotz | Klotz finds himself in the dog house of the Adirondack Phantoms having trouble getting ice time and is scratched most nights, Garrett has tremendous size at 6'6 and could develop into an NHL enforcer within 5 years if he gets the ice time he needs in the American League |
| 50 | Chris McAllister | Chris is currently playing in the Central Hockey League which is disappointing I would love to see him wear an AHL jersey some day soon, last season he played some time in the EIHL and was with Hershey of the AHL the year before. Chris is 6'8 240 pounds |
| 51 | Martin Grenier | Martin is wasting his time in the fight-less KHL picking up a nice paycheck, he last played for the Philadelphia Phantoms in the 2007-2008 season where he saw just 34 games but managed to log 78 penalty minutes and a great winning record against the AHL's heavies |
| 52 | Mike Hoffman | Mike Hoffman is currently a free agent, last season Mike was injured and never really got over his injury. Mike is a huge individual at 6'5 250 pounds, Mike usually only logs about 4 minutes of ice time in the AHL, Mike will most likely never find himself in the NHL due to lack of skating ability but can still be a capable AHL enforcer |
| 53 | Brad Herauf | Brad is new to the AHL after spending a lot of time in the ECHL and is currently fighting in the middleweight division |
| 54 | Nicolas Blanchard | Nic is new to the enforcer game after logging a lot of penalty minutes last season |
| 55 | Zack Fitzgerald | Can't seem to make it to the NHL, still a capable AHL enforcer |
| 56 | Benn Olson | Has trouble sticking in the AHL, lately seems to find himself with the Everblades. Hopefully he can work up to the AHL |
| 57 | Jeremy Yablonski | B-Sens Alternate Captain and has a great fighting record in the AHL |
| 58 | Tim Spencer | Another Sen, has proved he can be a heavyweight early in the 09-10 season |
| 59 | Trevor Gillies | Bridgeport already has lots of muscle with Rechlicz, Morency, Westgarth and Haley but they added some more with a legit AHL enforcer in Gillies |
| 60 | Pascal Morency | Takes a lot of penalty minutes which is awesome |
| 61 | Brett Westgarth | Physical d-man and can fight both the middles and the heavies |
| 62 | Josh Gratton | Realistically should be in the NHL but isn't |
| 63 | Paul Crosty | Is playing great so far in Grand Rapids, racking up the fighting majors |
| 64 | Ryan Flinn | Good to see he is back with Rockford after being released earlier in the season, too bad its just a PTO though |
| 65 | Eric Neilson | Glad to see Bulldogs giving him a chance after a great outing last year against the AHL top heavies |
| 66 | Alex Henry | Big 6'5 guy, too bad he can't find NHL employment but is a top D-man in the AHL |
| 67 | Brent Henley | Having a weak 2009-2010 season with very few fights, played his way into the AHL last year but could be playing his way out of it this year |
| 68 | Greg Amadio | Fights a lot but not very good at it, reminds me a bit of Dallas' Krys Barch |
| 69 | Grant McNeill | Currently injured, too bad because he had a great year last year |
| 70 | Brandon Sugden | Suspended by Hershey and signed with Russia. SOB. |
| 71 | Theo Peckham | Physical d-man but isn't playing that way this year especially with the big club in Edmonton |
| 72 | Matt Kassian | Could be in the NHL next year when the Boogeyman hits free agency |
| 73 | Louis Robitaille | Takes a hell load of penalty minutes and fights a lot, is good for 300 + penalty minutes a season |
| 74 | Kevin Cormier | new to the AHL, needs to fight more to keep his spot. Looks like a nerd |
| 75 | Rob Davison | after a lack luster year with Vancouver Rob has found himself in the minors and is playing real well so far. Could find himself back with the NHL soon |
| 76 | Kevin Westgarth | Has improved his fighting skills over the years |
| 77 | Tom Maxwell | a good fit in Manitoba and is racking up the penalty minutes and fighting the big boys in the AHL |
| 78 | Matt McCue | big boy and a good fighter in the preseason but having a weak regular season fight card |
| 79 | Matt Walker | tough guy but doesn't fight enough |
| 80 | Guillaume Desbiens | good power forward and fighter |
| 81 | Nathan McIver | Can't keep in the NHL, fights a lot which is nice |
| 82 | Nathan Perrott | Currently retired, great tough guy |
| 83 | Triston Grant | has a great shot at making the NHL next year, reminds me a bit of Hordichuk |
| 84 | Mitch Fritz | Big man who doesn't fight enough, great fighter |
| 85 | Mitch Love | Lots of fights last season but not so much this season, he needs to fight a bit more in Peoria |
| 86 | Guillaume Lefebvre | Is NHL ready, could make the NHL soon. Tough as nails will fight anybody |
| 87 | Jeff Cowan | Worst fighter in hockey history |
| 88 | Brett Clouthier | Glad to see him back in the AHL, too bad his ice time is limited. I think he could leave the AHL next year for more ice time. Released from Providence today, is free to sign with whoever |
| 89 | Jimmy Bonneau | Brilliant so far in Rochester with 11 fights, Keep it up JIm |
| 90 | Ryan Donally | Sent back to Bakersfield, I feel for him but I think Anaheim should lend him to Lake Erie who just had Bordeleau doing the dirty work |
| 91 | Francis Lessard | Big time penalty minute man and an AHL vet |
| 92 | Kip Brennan | another AHL veteran, top 5 fighter in the AHL. Tough as nails |
| 93 | Riley Emmerson | Back in the ECHL, too bad but he is 6'8 250 pounds but still loses a lot of fights |
| 94 | Jon "Nasty" Mirasty | One of the top heavies in the AHL despite being only 5'10 |
| 95 | Kevin Harvey | had a lot of fights last season and is keeping it up this year |
| 96 | Adam Huxley | is able to play in the AHL but can't catch a break |
| 97 | Francis Wathier | good middleweight fighter, could make the NHL within 3 years |
| 98 | Sean McMorrow | Is a really great guy and a great fighter |
| 99 | Luke Gazdic | New to the AHL, could be in the AHL within 3 years |
| 100 | Phil Oreskovic | I think he is capable to be in the NHL, could be a good fit in Florida organization |
| 101 | Andre Deveaux | needs to be trade and is wasting his time in the AHL, also isn't fighting as much as last year |
| 102 | Richard Greenop | NHL enforcer quality within a few years |
| 103 | Brennan Evans | good AHL defenseman and fights a lot |
| 104 | Frazer McLaren | Good to see him getting time in the NHL, a very capable AHL enforcer |
| 105 | Jesse Boulerice | screwed up his career in the NHL with suspensions and lack of fighting, got a 2 game stint with the Oil last year but only tallied a tripping penalty and NO FIGHTS, at least he is fighting a lot in the American League |
| 106 | Wade Brookbank | He is welcome on my NHL team anytime he wants, any team could use this guy. He is such a hard worker but just can't stick with the big team. If I was an NHL GM Wade would be my first free agent signing |
| 107 | Aaron Boogaard | Isn't far from the NHL, free agent year coming up but I hope he gets and NHL deal |
| 108 | Mike Sgroi | Currently playing with the Laredo Bucks. Seems to get an AHL tryout every year but can't stick |
| 109 | Tanner Glass | Glad to see him in the NHL, has had a brilliant year so far with Van City. My 4th line is Hordi-Ryp-Glass. get rid of wellwood |
| 110 | Hans Benson | Started out with San Antonio and signed a deal with an ECHL team but now finds himself signed to a PTO with Portland who was lacking a capable enforcer. Hasn't fought a lot in Portland which could be his downfall. It was his downfall as he was released on the 23rd of November |
| 111 | Dale Purinton | Currently Retired: A real goon |
| 112 | Joe Rullier | keeps on signing in Europe for some reason |
| 113 | Brett Gallant | middleweight size, heavyweight fists |
| 114 | Adam Keefe | sticks up for teammates but loses most of his fights. currently a free agent |
| 115 | Cody McLeod | Middleweight size, decent fighter and is capable of playing the 3rd line |
| 116 | Daniel Carcillo | Another middleweight fighter but isn't fighting a lot in the 2009-2010 season which is disappointing |
| 117 | Johnny Boychuk | Playing 7th defenseman with the Bruins, decent middleweight fighter |
| 118 | Steve Montador | Again a middleweight tough guy 5-6 defenseman. The only toughness Buffalo has now |
| 119 | Ian Laperriere | The man they call Lappy. Fights the heavies and a good leader, also fights the middleweights |
| 120 | Sidney Crosby | Fights sometimes which is cool, I used to like Ovechkin but he does too much media bullshit. |
| 121 | Ryan Hollweg | |
| 122 | Ryan Getzlaf | |
| 123 | Marc-Andre Roy | |
| 124 | Nick Kypreos | |