| # | Player | Comments |
| 1 | David Walker | Pound for Pound one of the toughest guys in the ECHL. Throws with both hands well and is seemingly never over matched in a fight. Great technical fighter. |
| 2 | Stan Jonathan | Just plain TOUGH! Didn't fight a ton but when he did it was exciting! |
| 3 | P.J. Stock | Super strong for small guy. One of, if not the, most entertaining fighters to watch of the past 15 years. Win or lose you knew it was going to be a damn good effort. |
| 4 | Jon "Nasty" Mirasty | All of his fights are fun to watch. Whether he gets knocked out by Bosse or he goes toe toe toe with another dude, "Nasty" IS the most entertaining fighter of all time. |
| 5 | Tony Twist | One of the best Heavy's of all time. Beat up some really tough customers and didn't back down. BIG shots always. |
| 6 | Steve MacIntyre | Great all around fighter. He can beat you technically or beat you just throwing bombs toe to toe. Hope he sticks in the NHL (09/10) becasue he could be the league's best heavy for years to come. |
| 7 | Kevin Cormier | Toughest guy I have ever seen fight at the Junior level. Can play a bit too but fell into the role of fighter - to which he is great at - just check his record with only 2 recorded losses on his record. Has had hand problems in the past with a couple of breaks but will still beat the shit out of you! |
| 8 | D.J. King | Throws BOMBS. Tough as hell. Doesn't lose much. Nuff said. |
| 9 | Brett Gallant | |